Outcome: Majority Verdict.
Ratio decidendi: The go to place for portugese tarts in Sydney. Each bite is accompanied by the resounding crunch of puff pastry that can be heard in a 3 mile radius of this unassuming pastry shop. Whether the warm custardy filling is too sweet for your liking is another question but there’s no shortage of baked goodies on offer if you’d like something else.
Obiter dicta: If you’re in the area and have any semblance of an appetite, Frango on the opposite side of the road probably has arguably the best charcoal chicken in sydney.